Behind the Work: How NMHED Strengthens Higher Education

The New Mexico Higher Education Department works behind the scenes to help institutions navigate challenges, strengthen accountability, and ensure students remain at the center of every decision. This page highlights recent examples of that work and the leadership efforts that supported institutional recovery and stability.

Op-ed from Gerald Hoehne Chief of Staff, New Mexico Higher Education Department 

From crisis to recovery: The Higher Education Department

When an institution is in trouble, the problems can pile up quickly. From the outside, the damage appears irreversible. It takes a significant, collective effort— sometimes the comprehensive work of an entire government agency—to not only stop the landslide but to begin the painstaking work of rebuilding.

The New Mexico Higher Education Department has been that agency, and I want to share a positive, but often unheard, story about two of our state's institutions that are now on the path to recovery thanks to our dedicated, hands-on involvement. Just a few years ago, Mesalands Community College was teetering on the brink of closing due to misuse of funds and other financial issues. Financial mismanagement and internal turmoil threatened to close the school. After the previous leadership resigned in the wake of a faculty vote of no confidence, it seemed like the end was near. But in the past two years, Mesalands has achieved a remarkable turnaround. The New Mexico Higher Education Department worked directly with new college leadership to rectify broken financial systems and establish robust new internal controls. We didn't just offer advice; we were in the weeds, helping to rebuild the school's fiscal foundation from the ground up. The department also acted as the school’s chief advocate, securing essential emergency funding from the legislature and the state Board of Finance to bridge the gap and restore stability. This active intervention was critical.

Today, Mesalands has positive fund balances, positive cash flow, and stabilized enrollment. This isn’t a miracle; it's a testament to the hard work of the faculty, staff, and the community of Tucumcari, all of whom were instrumental in creating the conditions for this ongoing recovery, with our department leading the effort. Western New Mexico University faced a different kind of crisis, but one that was just as damaging. Publicized allegations of inappropriate spending by its former president eroded public trust and led to a leadership vacuum. Our department initiated investigations into the financial allegations and then stepped in to manage the day-to-day operations after the president and board resigned. We held weekly meetings, trained a new board of regents, and even provided direct support during a recent cyberattack. By working collaboratively with the university and helping to guide its functions, we kept it moving forward and set it on a path toward a more stable future. We’re still on the road to full stability, but the university is on a stronger trajectory because the department was there every step of the way, providing the leadership and stability it desperately needed. There are no quick fixes for deep-seated problems. Charting the course and keeping it on track requires patience, foresight, and a steady hand.

The New Mexico Higher Education Department wants the communities of New Mexico to feel confident that we will continue to provide that additional layer of security and assistance. Our work goes beyond crisis management to include regular oversight and training that helps all our higher education institutions thrive. The department carries out this essential work in the background, with no expectation of public acclaim. We view these initiatives as a core part of our mission and our responsibility, and we are proud to fulfill them on behalf of the people of New Mexico. Because when our colleges succeed, our students—and our state—succeed.

Op-Ed Featured in:

Institutional Support and Accountability Timelines

November 16, 2022 Mesalands Community College (MCC) President Gregory Busch sent a letter to New Mexico Higher Education Department (NMHED) Capital Projects Director Gerald Hoehne notifying him that the independent community college is experiencing a shortage of funds and needs assistance in meeting fiscal obligations through a release of capital funds.

November 18, 2022 The NMHED Institutional Finance Division External Audit Manager Scott Eccles wastasked with developing a letter of fiscal concern to MCC regarding their inquiry.

November 28, 2023 The letter of fiscal concern was sent to President Busch from NMHED Cabinet Secretary Stephanie M. Rodriguez.

December 14, 2022 MCC President Busch attended a meeting with the higher education institution’s executive staff, Cabinet Secretary Rodriguez, and senior staff at the NMHED to communicate that the college is undergoing a cash flow deficiency in which scheduled staff and faculty payrolls will soon not be met. President Busch and the independent community college’s Chief Financial Officer (CFO) Blanca Pauliukevicius stated that in addition to MCC’s Fiscal Year (FY) 2021 and FY2022 audits both being late, there is an 18-month backlog of accounting transactions and reconciliations and as a result, CFO Pauliukevicius was not sure of the higher education institution’s current fiscal health picture. Additionally, she currently does not have the ability to produce cash flow statements. President Busch and CFO Pauliukevicius communicated that MCC’s financial system is currently unsustainable due to most data being kept off the books and the fact that it requires manual entries, it is time consuming, and the assets are not being properly tracked. MCC also communicated that institutional data is missing and what has been submitted to the state agency is not credible. President Busch disclosed that many documents had been shredded or destroyed by former employees. The NMHED staff from the Institutional Finance Division requested balances from CFO Pauliukevicius for unrestricted cash and unrestricted fund balance and, additionally, any and all other unrestricted funds. The NMHED also communicated options for MCC to request an emergency loan from the State Board of Finance (SBOF) and the possibility of requesting advanced monthly state appropriations via the “50% rule” from the New Mexico Department of Finance and Administration (DFA). The Institutional Finance Division staff communicated that MCC will need to produce credible financial documents for a loan or advanced appropriations to be considered.

December 22, 2022 CFO Pauliukevicius communicated unrestricted cash reserves are at $300,000 and an additional $946,527 in a certificate of deposit account (savings). CFO Pauliukevicius calculated monthly payroll at approximately $575,000, including benefits, and monthly state general fund appropriations at $385,000.

January 18, 2023 Secretary Rodriguez designated MCC under NMHED’s Enhanced Fiscal Oversight Program (EFOP).

January 24, 2023 CFO Pauliukevicius communicated available unrestricted cash reserves are down to $192,170 and the higher education institution’s cash flow is negative.

January 25, 2023 The NMHED met with DFA Principal Analyst Nicole Macias, Legislative Finance Committee (LFC) staff, Senator Pat Woods, Representative Jack Chatfield, President Busch, and MCC’s executive staff. MCC provided an overview of the higher education institution’s current fiscal health status and LFC requested documents from the higher education institution including payroll reports, expenditure and revenue analysis, cash flow analysis, a short-term fiscal solvency plan, FY23 supplemental funding request breakdowns, a review of Mesalands Community College Foundation (MCC Foundation) funds available, and a long-term strategic and fiscal plan. Many of these requests were also outlined in the EFOP letter signed by Secretary Rodriguez.

January 30, 2023 NMHED External Audit Manager Scott Eccles provided legal documents to CFO Pauliukevicius pertaining to MCC Foundation being a non-legal component unit of MCC.

 February 1, 2023 Staff from the NMHED traveled to MCC to perform a site visit. During this visit, President Busch communicated that he made the decision to perform an internal salary study and give raises to existing staff to bring them up to the salary mean and to also attract staff from outside the geographical area of MCC due to the rural nature of the college and limited job applicant pool. In addition, President Busch explained that two cost of living raises that were legislatively appropriated and funded from previousfiscal years had never been issued to staff and faculty, so as a result, President Busch, with Board of Trustees (BOT) approval, adjusted salaries accordingly. President Busch stated that soon after this action Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham and the Legislature enacted a seven percent compensation increase, which was not anticipated by MCC. External Audit Manager Eccles discussed weekly and monthly EFOP reporting requirements with MCC CFO Pauliukevicius. CFO Pauliukevicius communicated that current unrestricted reserves are at $300,000, which includes the certificate of deposit (savings) and that the staff and faculty payroll scheduled for February 10, 2023 will not be met. 

February 3, 2023 NMHED Finance Division Senior Budget Analyst Debbie Garcia completes requested FY23 salary analysis and budget comparisons. External Audit Manager Eccles requested fiscal cost analysis for the multiple salary increases decided by President Busch. External Audit Manager Eccles is of the opinion that President Busch made decisions (which were approved by the BOT) to increase salaries at a time when MCC did not have the fiscal reserves and future funding sources necessary to absorb the increases. It was also noted there was no CFO on staff during the time President Busch made and the BOT approved these decisions. The documentation requested from the meeting on January 25, 2023, was submitted to the NMHED and LFC.

February 5, 2023 The Colleges Executive team, and faculty & staff senate gave votes of no confidence at the BOT meeting on President Busch and the BOT citing concerns with leadership and governance.

February 6, 2023 The NMHED was informally notified that President Busch resigned. CFO Pauliukevicius shared with the Institutional Finance Division staff that some incidental revenues have been received and the unrestricted operating account is up to $1,037,650 with an additional $482,420 remaining in certificate of deposit (started at $927,190 used for last payroll); therefore, February 10, 2023, scheduled payroll will be met. CFO Pauliukevicius communicated the payroll scheduled for February 24, 2023 will not be met unless supplemental funding or additional incidental revenues can be obtained. NMHED Capital Projects Director Gerald Hoehne forwarded MCC executive leadership complaints to NMHED External Audit Manager Scott Eccles which included accusations that that President Busch made progressive salary increase decisions, disregarded warnings about the college’s limited finances, and threatened to fire executive staff who revealed the cash shortfall/deficit until after his employment contract was renewed.

February 7, 2023 The NMHED was notified that President Busch had not resigned but instead was placed on medical leave.

February 8, 2023 External Audit Manager Eccles provided weekly and monthly EFOP reporting requirements to MCC CFO Pauliukevicius. The first weekly EFOP report is due February 11, 2023, and first monthly EFOP report is due March 1, 2023.

February 9, 2023 NMHED issues MCC summary report from February 1st formal site visit.

February 11, 2023 NMHED receives the first weekly EFOP report from MCC CFO Blanca Pauliukevicius.

February 14, 2023 The Colleges BOT approves MCC executive team recommendations to impose a fiscal solvency plan that includes across the board salary reductions varying in percent based upon level of compensation, immediate hiring and travel freezes, elimination of low-enrollment classes, elimination of cross country and golf, increases in fitness center fees, and consolidation of contracts. The BOT appoint Dr. Allen Moss as Acting President. NMHED Cabinet Secretary Stephanie Rodriguez sends letter of concern to State Auditor Joseph Maestas requesting special audit of MCC.

February 15, 2023 NMHED Cabinet Secretary Stephanie Rodriguez sends letter of concern to Attorney General Raul Torrez requesting special audit of MCC.

February 21, 2023 NMHED and MCC executive teams make formal emergency funding request at SBOF meeting and the College is awarded a grant of $763,650. MCC Board of Trustees (BOT) appoints Dr. Allen Moss as Interim President.

February 22, 2023 NMHED and Office of State Auditor (OSA) audit officials meet to discuss and plan special audit of MCC.

February 28, 2023 NMHED and MCC executive leadership provide supplemental funding proposal to LFC leadership to support re-implementation and staff training of the College’s financial software system

March 1, 2023 MCC BOT Chair and Foundation Treasurer James Streetman submits formal letter of resignation. NMHED receives the first monthly EFOP report from MCC’s CFO Blanca Pauliukevicius.

March 2, 2023 MCC’s accrediting agency the Higher Learning Commission (HLC) formally places the College under “Financial Distress Designation”, which is a consumer protection mechanism to apprise the pubic when current conditions at an accredited college or university raise serious questions about its resource base to support its educational programs. State Auditor Joseph Maestas issues formal response letter to NMHED Cabinet Secretary Rodriguez requesting assistance in obtaining $200,000 legislative appropriation to conduct a special audit of MCC.

March 10, 2023 MCC President Dr. Gregory Busch submits formal letter of resignation. 

March 16, 2023 MCC BOT Vice-Chair Teresa Stephenson assumes the role of BOT Chair with the March 1st resignation of Chair James Streetman. The BOT officially names Dr. Allen Moss as Interim President (was Acting President).

March 20, 2023 NMHED Auditor Eccles reviewed the consulting agreement between MCC and JT Kim allowing for twenty hours a week for accounts reconciliation.

March 31, 2023 NMHED initiated forwarding of weekly EFOP reports to the OSA as requested.

April 1, 2023 NMHED receives the second monthly EFOP report from MCC’s CFO Blanca Pauliukevicius.

April 6, 2023 MCC BOT appoint Richard Primrose as new Trustee to replace recently resigned Trustee James Streetman.

April 25, 2023 MCC’s FY2021 late audit is released by the OSA showing a disclaimed opinion over financial statements and an adverse opinion over federal awards including 17 audit findings. NMHED Auditor Eccles reviewed the CFO’s corrective action plan responses for each finding.

April 26, 2023 NMHED Cabinet Secretary Rodriguez received letter from State Auditor Maestas communicating MCC is designated for special audit due to serious concerns regarding the College’s Foundation specifically financial leadership and operations, and the ability to continue future operations.

May 1, 2023 NMHED receives the third monthly EFOP report from MCC’s CFO Blanca Pauliukevicius

May 11, 2023 MCC Interim President Moss notified NMHED of four pending lawsuits by former employees who were terminated under former President Busch.

May 19, 2023 MCC has communications meeting with the LFC announcing reductions and resignations in underperforming academic programs, further personnel reductions, update on Jenzabar timeline for re-implementation, and addition of joint academic programs for area high school students.

June 1, 2023 NMHED receives the fourth monthly EFOP report from MCC’s CFO Blanca Pauliukevicius

June 2, 2023 NMHED performed a second site visit at MCC as part of the EFOP designation. The site visit included a Governing Board Training session presented by NMHED’s Cabinet Secretary and executive leadership that focused on fiduciary and legal responsibilities and NMHED’s oversight role specific to budgets, fiscal health evaluations, special verifications, academic policy, and financial aid. Small group meeting were also conducted to review internal processes and discuss policies, procedures, and resources used to accomplish daily activities at MCC. Department of Finance and Administration Budget Analyst Nicole Macias attended and observed the site visit.

June 9, 2023 NMHED Interim Finance Director Hoehne met with MCC Interim President Moss and obtained status on cash flow, contract staff, current staffing levels, site visit feedback, and the Jenzabar implementation.

June 27, 2023 NMHED received notification from MCC Interim President Moss that Consultant Judy Scharmer who is retired Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of New Mexico Military Institute (NMMI) has been contracted “to provide support in navigating the current financial situation and assist in communicating with NMHED”.

July 1, 2023 NMHED receives the fifth monthly EFOP report from MCC’s CFO Blanca Pauliukevicius. MCC President Moss communicates he is hiring retired New Mexico Military Institute CFO Judy Scharmer as consultant to the business office, procurement, and budgets.

July 20, 2023 NMHED Auditor Eccles received confirmation email from New Mexico Bank & Trust’s Vice President stating that MCC’s account was credited the $39,775 on July 19, 2023 for the forged check. Auditor Eccles noted the OSA was also copied as required by the Audit Act

August 1, 2023 NMHED receives the sixth monthly EFOP report from MCC’s CFO Blanca Pauliukevicius.

August 4, 2023 NMHED issues MCC summary report from June 2nd formal site visit.

August 24, 2023 NMHED Finance Division External Audit Manager Scott Eccles and Academics & Policy Division Analyst Kathleen Sena both confirmed their attendance at MCC’s upcoming HLA accreditation site visit scheduled for September 12 and 13 at MCC’s campus in Tucumcari. 

August 29, 2023 NMHED notified by MCC Interim President Moss that CFO Blanca Pauliukevicius will be leaving employment as MCC’s CFO. NMHED noting that consultant Judy Scharmer who is retired CFO from New Mexico Military Institute is under contract for professional services. NMHED Cabinet Secretary Rodriguez, Interim Finance Director Hoehne, and External Audit Manager Eccles met virtually with Senator Pat Woods from District 7 to discuss the status at MCC. Mr. Hoehne provided an overview of funding obtained for the College including current restricted funds and unrestricted cash balances. In addition, Mr. Hoehne summarized work done by NMHED in performing two on campus site visits in February and June. Mr. Hoehne included the fact that NMHED requires both weekly and monthly financial reports from MCC in order to properly track cash flows to ensure payrolls are being met. Senator Wood had concerns with enrollment in which Mr. Hoehne provided current enrollment figures including an increase in total number of students. Mr. Hoehne provided an update on the audit status including the special audit to be conducted by the OSA. Mr. Hoehne stated he is concerned not only about recent hail and storm damage to the campus but as to the lack of overall maintenance and facilities on campus in general. Senator Woods stated he will plan to tour the campus so he can assess accordingly. Cabinet Secretary Rodriguez instructed Audit Manager Eccles to create a timeline for Senator Pete Campos from District 8 and Representative Jack Chatfield from District 67 who both could not attend today’s communications meeting.

September 7, 2023 OSA Investigations Director Mr. Shawn Beck communicated the scope of the special audit to include the following areas within the time frame July 1, 2018, through April 30, 2023:
1. College and Board of Trustees leadership and management decisions, actions, and practices regarding leases between the College and the Foundation during the Period.
2. College and Board of Trustees and Foundation and Board of Directors leadership and management decisions, actions, and practices regarding the use of and accounting for federal grant and endowment funds held by the College and/or Foundation during the Period.
3. College and Board of Trustees and Foundation and Board of Directors leadership and management decisions, actions, and practices, regarding use of and accounting for, monetary and in-kind contributions to the College, any of its departments or museums, or to the Foundation, for use in support of, or on behalf of, the College, any of its departments or museums, during the Period.
4. College and Board of Trustees leadership and management decisions, actions, and practices regarding staff recruitment, hiring, and salary increases during the Period.
5. College use of legislatively appropriated staff compensation increase funding during the Period.
6. College actions and practices regarding college financial reporting and updating to College leadership and Board of Trustees during the Period. 7. College and Board of Trustees leadership and management decisions, actions, and practices regarding oversight agency approval to increase budget authority during the Period.
8. College and Board of Trustees and Foundation and Board of Directors leadership and management decisions, actions, and practices regarding conflict of interest and nepotism during the Period.
9. Financial impact of decisions made by the College and Board of Trustees and Foundation and Board of Directors leadership and management during the Period.
10. Analysis of College component unit determinations during the Period.

September 12-13, 2023 NMHED Finance Division’s External Audit Manager Scott Eccles and Academic Affairs & Policy Division Research Analyst Kathleen Sena traveled to MCC’s campus in Tucumcari as observers of the Higher Learning Commission’s (HLC) two-day site visit.

September 28, 2023 MCC’s Interim President Moss communicated NMHED’s Finance Division that CFO Blanca Pauliukevicius last day is today and that Tammy Hall in the MCC’s Business Office will be responsible for providing future weekly and monthly EFOP reports. NMHED Finance Division’s Senior Budget Analyst Debbie Garcia communicating concern via email to NMHED Interim Finance Director Gerald Hoehne and NMHED External Audit Manager Scott Eccles regarding Mesalands FY2024 Operating Budget due to “variances with each revision of the BARS and Operating Budget over the past few months continue to be moving targets and continue to raise Red flags”. Debbie also communicated she has had to require the College to resubmit their FY2024 Operating Budget twelve times due to these uncorrected variances and as such, she still cannot approve the Operating Budget that was originally due May 1, 2023. Auditor Eccles noted and communicated to Director Hoehne and Senior Budget Analyst Garcia that heavy turnover in the President and Chief Financial Officer positions has directly affected the College’s ability to submit an Operating Budget in compliance with New Mexico Administrative Code (NMAC) and NMHED required template. This noted turnover includes having four Presidents over the past five years in which two have been Interim and having four Chief Financial Officers over the last three years.

September 29, 2023 NMHED received notification from MCC Interim President Moss that Consultant David Gray who is retired Controller of NMMI has been contracted to provide accounting and strategic assistance.

October 6, 2023 NMHED Chief Financial Officer Mario Suazo approved Mesalands FY2024 operating budget based upon the recommendation of NMHED Finance Division’s Senior Budget Analyst Debbie Garcia.

October 31, 2023 The draft economic study report on MCC performed by Lightcast was released on October 31, 2023 for comments. The Higher Learning Commission (HLC) placed MCC under “Probation” status effective October 31, 2023. The HLC previously had placed MCC under a “Financial Distress” status effective March 2, 2023. The College is still accredited under Probation status but will be subject to increased HLC monitoring and advisory visits.

November 17, 2023 NMHED issued the Request for Proposal for the MCC Feasibility Study in which $250,000 was appropriated by the State’s Legislature during the 2023 legislative session.

November 20, 2023 MCC was placed under the U.S. Department of Education’s (DOE) Heightened Cash Monitoring 1 (HCM1) payment method to ensure additional oversight of cash management. The College was placed on HCM1 due to late financial audits for FY2021 and FY2022. As a result, the College is required to a $61,652 to DOE to satisfy any debts or liabilities owed.

November 27, 2023 NMHED receives notification from MCC Interim President Moss that Consultant Judy Scharmer’s contract is being renewed for five months.

December 14, 2023 Office of State Auditor (OSA) Investigations Division Director Shawn Beck held the MCC special audit entrance conference along with Jaramillo Accounting Group’s (JAG) management Audrey Jaramillo and Scott Eliason. Also attending the conference from the OSA included Investigations Audit Supervisor Alanna Goodman. MCC staff in attendance included Interim President Dr. Allen Moss, Mr. Josh Mcvey, Matt Martinez, Joel Kiser, Margaret Ragland, Foundation Chair Bidigan, Board Chair Primrose, and others. NMHED External Audit Manager Scott Eccles was also in attendance. JAG’s management/audit Lead Audrey Jaramillo had many preliminary questions in which MCC’s President and staff offered answers. External Audit Manager Eccles reiterated the appropriation is to determine the facts behind the cash flow shortage communicated by the College’s President in November of 2022 and offered a meeting with JAG in accordance with the State Audit Rule (2.2.2.15) and the sharing of information specific to “special audits”.
Office of State Auditor (OSA) held the exit conference for MCC’s FY 2022 annual audit. As such, the College’s FY2022 audit should be released before February 2024.

January 17, 2024 As part of the EFOP and in consideration of continued concern over outstanding audits (FY22 and FY23) and the College being without a Chief Financial Officer for the past four months, NMHED’s Finance Division requested current detailed unaudited financial data from MCC including Revenues, Expenditures, Outstanding Liabilities, Unrestricted Reserves, and detailed expenditure and balance summaries for the 2023 House Bill (HB)2 special appropriation and the 2023 State Board of Finance (SBOF) emergency grant. NMHED requested that the cash flow statement information be developed/prepared by Judy Scharmer who has been a financial Consultant to the College’s (June of 2023) since retiring as New Mexico Military Institute’s Chief Financial Officer.

January 19, 2024 MCC has now been under NMHED’s EFOP for one-year (since January 18, 2023) which includes the submittal of fifty weekly cash flow statements.

January 27, 2024 NMHED received a portion of the financial data previously requested on January 17, 2024 from MCC’s Interim President Moss.

January 30, 2024 NMHED received a second email containing the remaining financial data previously requested on January 17, 2024 from MCC’s Interim President Moss.

January 31, 2024 NMHED Finance Division performed a detailed review of the cash flow statement created by MCC’s Financial Consultant Judy Scharmer. It was determined that based upon estimates and considering using the remainder of House Bill 2 and State Board of Finance emergency loan funds, the College will end the fiscal year on June 30, 2024 with a balance of $245,000. It was noted that the College’s most recent weekly Enhanced Fiscal Oversight Program (EFOP) cash flow statement shows an unrestricted surplus within the operating bank account of approximately $1 million. Interim Finance Director Hoehne expressing concern over the long-term fiscal viability of the College.

February 1, 2024 NMHED Finance Division Interim Director Hoehne and External Audit Manager Eccles met with NMHED Cabinet Secretary Rodriguez to discuss continued concerns with the College’s ability to maintain longterm fiscal solvency based upon salary and fringe benefit costs still being high in relation to total operating expenditures (even after MCC instituted self-imposed salary cuts). Interim Director Hoehne communicated his concerns with the College ending FY2024 with minimal funds ($245,000). External Audit Manager Eccles communicated that the College carries a surplus of unrestricted cash in the operating bank account of approximately $1 million.

February 2, 2024 NMHED Interim Finance Division Gerald Hoehne and NMHED External Audit Manager Scott Eccles met virtually with MCC Interim President Moss and MCC’s contracted Financial Consultant Judy Scharmer to discuss the College’s fiscal health status and budget status. Interim Director Hoehne and External Audit Manager Eccles both expressed concern over whether the College is now operating within its budget after prior fiscal solvency measures taken which included salary cuts and vacancy savings. Consultant Scharmer stated she is confident the College is operating within revenues and believes the next step would be to try to start to build up unrestricted reserves. Consultant Scharmer communicated although she understands and was disappointed that the College received a disclaimed audit opinion for FY2022 from the State Auditor’s Office as she feels the reconciliations were completed and available for review. Ms. Scharmer stated she is optimistic for FY23’s audit will be much improved. NMHED staff requested and received a budget forecast for MCC through June 30, 2024, which is the end of the fiscal year. This information is needed to determine current budget status (expenditures to revenues) and to prepare NMHED for risks associated with the upcoming review of MCC’s FY2025 Operating Budget.

February 16, 2024 MCC’s FY2022 audit was released by the Office of State Auditor today. It is noted the College received 9 audit findings of which 8 were repeated and 5 were of material (significant impact) nature. It is also noted that the College received a disclaimed auditor’s opinion over financial statements (no opinion could be rendered) as was also the case in FY2021 in which the College received a total of 17 audit findings.

February 23, 2024 Through evaluation of the operating budget forecast requested by NMHED Finance staff and submitted by Mesalands President with the assistance of consultant Judy Scharmer (retired NMMI CF0), it was clarified that although the College has drastically reduced expenditures including salary cuts for all faculty and staff, the College is still not operating 100% within their allotted budget. It is even clearer now that without state supplemental funding received in 2023, it was not possible for the college to keep their doors open.

March 6, 2024 NMHED received notice from MCC’s Interim President Moss that the College has been placed under “accredited probation” status by their accrediting agency the Higher Learning Commission (HLC) effective February 29, 2024. The College is currently not meeting core accreditation criteria in several areas centered around adequate governance and fiscal health. 

March 8, 2024 NMHED External Audit Manager Eccles initiating communication with NMHED newly hired/promoted Senior Budget Analyst Dawn Webster by providing status update on Mesalands specific to risks associated with the College’s upcoming FY2025 operating budget submission.

March 15, 2024 MCC’s Board of Trustees publicly launches national search for President. It is noted the College is operating without a Chief Financial Officer for the past six months but instead is utilizing two consultants via contract who are retired fiscal officers of another in-state higher education institution.

April 4, 2024 MCC received notification from Deputy State Auditor Ricky Bejarano that the Office of State Auditor (OSA) will be conducting the College’s FY2024 annual audit. It is noted that the OSA has been the lead auditor for MCC’s FY22 and FY23 audits also.

April 19, 2024 NMHED Cabinet Secretary Stephanie Rodriguez received letter from State Auditor Joseph Maestas noting FY22 audit issues including disclaimed auditor opinions, staff shortages and untrained personnel, unfinished reconciliations, and lack of cooperation from Foundation Board members resulting in State Auditor Maestas requesting Cabinet Secretary Rodriguez’s special assistance. State Auditor Maestas also communicating the ongoing special audit of MCC has been postponed to facilitate the completion of the College’s FY23 audit.

April 22, 2024 NMHED Chief Financial Officer and Interim Finance Director Gerald Hoehne sent email to NMHED Procurement Officer Cecilia Roybal which included justification letter to award Request for Proposal (RFP) for the Mesalands Community College (MCC) Feasibility Study to MGT Consultants.

May 1, 2024 MCC Interim President Dr. Allen Moss submitted the College’s FY2025 Operating Budget that included his notes confirming the College’s budget includes a negative fund balance; the College is still not operating within budget but are close to breakeven point; FY2023 (late audit) is underway; and upcoming items of fiscal impact include the College’s share of the 3% pay increase, property and liability insurance increases of 30%, and a 15% increase in health insurance costs.

May 21, 2024 NMHED entered into a Professional Services Agreement with MGT Consultants to perform feasibility study on MCC. NMHED Auditor Scott Eccles held EFOP communications meeting with MCC Business Office staff members Tammy Hall and Rachelle Arias as requested by MCC Interim President Moss. Auditor Eccles provided a history of the EFOP and discussed weekly reporting requirements.

May 29, 2024 MCC feasibility study project initiation meeting held between NMHED and MGT Consultants. NMHED Chief Financial Officer Gerald Hoehne and new NMHED Finance Director Tana Martinez designated NMHED External Auditor Manager Scott Eccles as NMHED Project Manager as defined within MGT’s awarded proposal.

May 30, 2024 MCC Interim President Moss communicating by email that Ms. Rachelle Arias named new Director of Business Services and Ms. Judy Scharmer continues to be consulting CFO.

December 6, 2023 Searchlight NM publishes first article regarding WNMU non-resourceful spending patterns. December 8, 2023: NMHED sends formal letter to WNMU President Shepard communicating “concerns with recent news articles suggesting improprieties in the use of funding and resources.”

December 13, 2023 Legislative Finance Committee (LFC) hearing in which WNMU non-resourceful spending pattern concerns and questions were voiced by Senator Siah Hemphill.

January 5, 2024 NMHED sends formal letter to WNMU President Shepard communicating executive and legislative concerns with non-resourceful spending patterns.

January 10, 2024 Searchlight NM publishes second article regarding WNMU non-resourceful spending patterns.

February 14, 2024 NMHED sends formal letter to WNMU communicating receipt of WNMU legal response and of upcoming NMHED compliance audit.

June 4, 2024 NMHED sends formal letter to WNMU communicating upcoming NMHED compliance audit engagement conference.

July 15, 2024 NMHED holds engagement conference at WNMU to communicate the start of the compliance audit including objectives and scope.

August 5, 2024 NMHED sends formal email to WNMU requesting compliance audit source documents.

September 26, 2024 NMHED sends first follow-up email to WNMU regarding not receiving any of the compliance audit source documents requested on August 5, 2024.

November 18, 2024 State Auditor issues “Letter of Concern” and “Media Advisory” from special examination of WNMU titled “Waste of Public Resources” documenting 493 instances of noncompliance involving Travel and Procurement.

November 20, 2024 NMHED sends second follow-up email to WNMU regarding not receiving any of the compliance audit source documents requested on August 5, 2025.

November 20, 2024 WNMU uploads compliance audit source documents for one of the eight audit work-papers (work-paper #6 uploaded) that were requested by NMHED on August 5, 2025. NMHED noting an item requested is missing from work-paper #6.

December 3, 2024 NMHED sends third follow-up email to WNMU regarding not receiving the compliance audit source documents requested on August 5, 2024.

December 8, 2024 NMHED requests missing source document for work-paper #6 from WNMU.

December 9, 2024 WNMU uploads missing compliance audit source documents for work-paper #6.

December 11, 2024 WNMU uploads requested compliance audit source documents for work-paper #2 and work-paper #4.

December 19, 2024 WNMU uploads requested compliance audit source documents for work-paper #5.

December 20, 2024 WNMU President Shepard formally resigns. January 6, 2025: State Department of Justice files emergency motion to halt $1.9 million severance package given by WNMU Board of Regents to President Shepard.

January 7, 2025 WNMU Board of Regents resign at the request of the Governor.

February 24, 2025 NMHED sends formal letter to WNMU Interim President Jack Crocker communicating closure of the WNMU compliance audit “based on 2.2.2.15 New Mexico Administrative Code (NMAC) Special Audits and Examinations”.

March 7, 2025 NMHED sends formal letter to WNMU Interim President Jack Crocker communicating “NMHED is designating WNMU under the Enhanced Fiscal Oversight Program (EFOP) as defined under New Mexico Administrative Code (NMAC) 5.3.11.”

March 11, 2025 State Auditor’s Special Investigation Division requests work-papers associated with NMHED’s compliance audit of WNMU. 

April 9, 2025 Newly appointed WNMU Board of Regents plan to hire new President.

April 10, 2025 NMHED sends formal letter to WNMU Interim President Jack Crocker communicating “NMHED will not proceed with placing WNMU on the Enhanced Fiscal Oversight Program at this time.”

June 26, 2025 WNMU Board of Regents appoint Dr. Christopher Maples as Interim President.

July 2, 2025 State Ethics Commission files lawsuit against former WNMU President Shepard for misuse of public funds.

August 12, 2025 NMHED provided scanned WNMU compliance audit workpapers to the State Auditor’s Special Investigation Division. August 21, 2025: NMHED sends formal email to Office of State Auditor Special Investigations Division Director Shawn Beck communicating WNMU $3.3 million in lost revenue due to lower enrollment.

August 22, 2025 WNMU Board of Regents send letter notifying former President Shepard that the $1.9 million severance package is invalid due to violation of the Open Meetings Act

"Public trust is built through transparency, accountability, and a willingness to act when institutions need support. Our responsibility is to help New Mexico's colleges remain strong, stable, and focused on student success."

A Letter from Secretary Stephanie Rodriguez, Deputy Secretary Patricia Trujillo, and Chief of Staff Gerald Hoehne 

To the community of New Mexico, the stories of Mesalands Community College and Western New Mexico University remind us of something fundamental: when our institutions face hardship, New Mexicans do not walk away—we roll up our sleeves and get to work. Over the past several years, the New Mexico Higher Education Department has stood shoulder-to-shoulder with educators, staff, students and communities to stabilize, rebuild, and strengthen the colleges that so many families rely on. 

This work is not simple, and it is never quick. It requires trust, collaboration and a willingness to confront difficult realities with honesty and determination. But as we have seen, meaningful change is possible when an entire community—local leaders, faculty, staff, state partners and governing boards—commits to the hard work of recovery. 

As we look ahead, our message is simple: we will continue to be there. 

We will continue to provide the oversight, guidance, training and direct support needed to help every college in New Mexico remain strong, accountable and student-centered. Whether facing complex financial issues, governance challenges, or unforeseen crises, our commitment is unwavering. 

We do this work not for recognition, but because it is our responsibility to ensure that higher education in New Mexico remains a source of opportunity and pride. When our institutions thrive, they open doors for students, strengthen local economies and move our state forward. 

Thank you for your continued trust, partnership and belief in the power of education to transform lives and communities. Together, we will continue building a stronger, more resilient higher education system for all New Mexicans. 

With gratitude and commitment, 

Secretary Stephanie Rodriguez 
Deputy Secretary Patricia Trujillo, Ph.D. 
Chief of Staff Gerald Hoehne 
"Transparency builds trust, and trust strengthens education. When students, faculty, and staff know their institutions are accountable, stable, and supported, they can focus on what matters most: learning, teaching, and building a stronger future for New Mexico. Protecting that trust and putting student well-being first will always be among our highest responsibilities."
— Gerald Hoehne, Chief of Staff 2026